Payroll ยท Legacy / structural concerns
ADP Run Review
Legacy mass-market SMB payroll โ solid product with documented aggressive renewal-pricing pattern
Quick verdict
ADP Run is best for Mid-market and larger trades operations (25+ employees) needing complex multi-state, prevailing-wage, or union-compliance capacity that smaller SMB platforms don't handle โ and contractors who already have an established ADP relationship that's working well. Pricing: Sales-quoted pricing โ typically $79-$200+/mo base + $5-$10/employee depending on tier and negotiation. Documented aggressive renewal-rate increases, opaque sales-quoted pricing, cancellation friction, overkill for SMB โ for typical 2-25 employee shops, Gusto/OnPay are structurally better choices.
About ADP Run
ADP Run is ADP's SMB-tier payroll product โ a market leader by customer count and brand recognition, with mature tax-filing infrastructure and broad payroll feature coverage. The product itself is solid for what it does. The structural concerns are around the sales process, pricing transparency, and renewal-rate increases that have been documented in contractor forum sentiment over many years.
The sales process: ADP Run pricing is sales-quoted rather than published. You'll get a phone-call demo, a tailored quote, and pricing that depends partly on negotiation. Initial pricing is often competitive โ but the documented pattern is that ADP renewal pricing increases significantly each year, often 15-30% annually on accounts with no major change in employee count or feature usage. Cancellation is described in many forum threads as involving retention-call pressure and friction.
For mid-market trades shops (25+ employees) where the volume math may favor ADP's enterprise underwriting capacity, the product is credible โ particularly for shops needing complex multi-state compliance, prevailing-wage compliance, or union compliance that smaller SMB payroll platforms don't handle. For typical 2-25 employee trades shops, the combination of opaque pricing + aggressive renewal pattern + sales-process friction makes ADP a structurally worse choice than Gusto or OnPay.
We list ADP for completeness because most contractors encounter it via brand recognition and sales outreach. The honest editorial position: ADP works as a product but the commercial relationship is structurally less contractor-friendly than modern SMB-focused alternatives.
How it works
Phone-call demo + sales-quoted pricing. Onboarding handled by ADP sales team. Multi-tier feature options. Renewal happens annually with potential rate increases.
Pros & cons
What works
-
Mature tax-filing infrastructure with 75+ year track record
ADP has been processing payroll taxes since 1949. The compliance side is among the most mature in the market.
-
Capacity for mid-market complexity (multi-state, prevailing-wage, union)
ADP can handle complex compliance scenarios that smaller SMB platforms don't โ multi-state employee withholdings, prevailing-wage compliance for public-works projects, union-shop reporting. For mid-market trades operations, this depth is valuable.
-
Strong brand recognition
ADP is the household name in payroll. Customers and employees know what ADP is, which provides some intangible professional polish.
What doesn't
-
Documented aggressive renewal-rate increases
Forum threads consistently document ADP Run renewal-rate increases of 15-30% annually on accounts with no employee-count or feature changes. The pattern is widespread enough to be structural rather than isolated.
-
Opaque sales-quoted pricing
No published pricing. Quote requires phone demo + sales conversation. Negotiated pricing creates inconsistent customer experiences and makes comparison shopping difficult.
-
Cancellation process described as friction-heavy
Retention-call pressure, oral promises not in written contracts, and contract minimum terms not always made explicit upfront. Same pattern as many legacy SMB-software cancellation experiences.
-
Overkill for typical SMB trades shop
For 2-25 employee trades shops, ADP's complexity isn't needed and the pricing pattern makes it more expensive than Gusto or OnPay for equivalent feature coverage.
-
Support quality is variable
Account-management quality varies significantly. Some contractors report excellent dedicated-rep relationships; others describe being passed between unhelpful first-line agents.
Pricing
Sales-quoted pricing โ typically $79-$200+/mo base + $5-$10/employee depending on tier and negotiation
Affiliate disclosure: ADP affiliate channels exist but are oriented at accountant/bookkeeper referrals rather than editorial publishers.
Integrations
Frequently asked
Is ADP Run worth it for a 10-employee trades shop?
Probably not. The pricing pattern + sales-process friction make ADP structurally worse than Gusto or OnPay for typical SMB trades shops. ADP's depth becomes valuable at 25+ employees or with complex compliance needs.
What about the renewal-rate-increase pattern?
Documented widely in forum threads. Existing ADP customers report 15-30% annual increases on accounts with no changes. If you're on ADP currently, shop alternatives at every renewal โ don't assume the rate stays competitive.
Other payroll services
Gusto
Tier SThe modern SMB payroll favorite โ best affiliate economics in the entire WrenchStack universe ($300-$1,000+ per signup via PartnerStack)
OnPay
Tier SLean SMB payroll with flat pricing โ favorite of small trades shops who don't need Gusto's bolt-ons
Patriot Payroll
Tier SUltra-affordable payroll for 1-3 employee shops โ cheapest tax-filing payroll in the market
Hourly.io
Tier SPayroll + pay-as-you-go workers comp combined โ the only payroll service with WC built in, structurally relevant for trades
QuickBooks Payroll
Tier APayroll embedded in QuickBooks Online โ convenient for QBO users, mediocre as standalone product
Square Payroll
Tier APayroll embedded in Square ecosystem โ convenient for Square-POS users, narrow fit outside that context